Calendar

Anonymity Unbound – Cyber Babies vs. Cyber Bullies

cyberbullying2_05Before the Internet went corporate, a few keystrokes revealed plenty about a person … name, location, even where you had been online and for how long.  Now he or she can give you the finger (figuratively speaking) and the bully’s identity remains elusive.

They call it cyber bullying, and the National Crime Prevention Council reports it’s a problem that affects almost half of all American teens.  Without a shred of accountability, bad behavior has no consequences online.

But all that changed recently, when two court cases highlighted the inadequacy of the global village to rein in troublemakers. Attack on free speech?  Plague of political correctness?  Anarchy has reigned, except now the cyber bullies are getting sued by the cyber babies.

Consider the cyber cat fight between cover girl Liskula Cohen and fashion student Rosemary Port.  And it happened on Google, of all places.  Port created “Skanks in NYC” to verbally terrorize Cohen, gossiping that she was a “skank and a “ho” – anonymously, of course.  Last week, a judged ordered Google to undress the virtual assailant.  Now “Skanks” is suing Google back, as if the “Streisand effect” will get her sympathy?

As if America cares?

No stranger to vitriol, New York Times columnist Maureen Dowd confessed, “If I read all the vile stuff about me on the Internet, I’d never come to work.  I’d scamper off and live my dream of being a cocktail waitress in a militia bar in Wyoming.”

But America does care.  Parents and politicians alike have become besieged by a Gestalt-like climate.

In another court case, a judge reversed a misdemeanor conviction against Lori Drew, an adult who had taken part in an anonymous cyber bullying scheme that drove a teenager to suicide.

Wired reported the judge rationalization that prosecuting anyone for violating a website’s terms of service “would convert a multitude of otherwise innocent Internet users into misdemeanant criminals.”

They aren’t criminals?

Andy Beal, an “online reputation management consultant” (cyber cleaner/fixer), observed that anonymity is coming to an end on the web.  It will be a business decision.

“I’ve seen too many companies have their reputation burned by an anonymous blogger–one that is just as likely to be a competitor fabricating lies, as a real customer. So, if you have plans to attack anyone’s reputation, don’t assume that you can do so in the safety of anonymity.”

CNET’s Chris Matyszczyk acknowledged that a virtual riot act might soon be read soon by the courts.

“I know that some people have pleasures that are not entirely innocent.

They go to sites such as What Would Tyler Durden Do? or Dlisted to read the occasionally besmirching remark aimed at those more famous, wealthy, and beautiful than themselves.

Sometimes, the bloggers behind these bastions of moral sure-footedness prefer to remain anonymous.”

Matyszczyk noted how Port’s attorney in the cyber catfight case claimed that blogs “have evolved as the modern-day soapbox for personal opinions.

Defending blogs, the attorney argued that these venues serve as “mere venting purposes, affording the less outspoken a protected forum for voicing gripes, leveling invective and ranting about anything at all.”

The judge didn’t buy it.  Cohen is entitled to know who called her “psychotic, lying, whoring…skank.”

Reality check … Just look at Britain’s House of Commons if you need a taste of lawmakers chewing on each other’s reputations like body parts.  Dirty laundry is a daily part of American politics.

Free speech in the United States was drawn from how Peter Zenger antagonized a pre-revolutionary governor in New York.  Zenger was arrested for rightfully exposing corruption and he did it with his own name.

Anonymity has a way of turning reasonable human beings into cruel jerks.

Maybe the solution is an online driver’s license but there are moments when confidentiality protects everything from a breaking news story to a Federal indictment.  One can imagine an unscrupulous politician turning such an online database into the staging ground for intimidation and censorship.

The Baltimore Sun defended anonymity.

”Our whistle-blowers, victims of domestic abuse and community activists need to be protected with anonymity, just as our bullied minors and libeled business owners need to be able to defend themselves from malicious liars.”

However, as Maureen Dowd concluded, “anonymity on the Internet is often less about being constructive and more about being cowardly.”

Category : Featured and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , .
« »

Comment:

  • Ryan Anthony

    I think people are forgetting something .. . You can always turn the computer off and walk away.

    • Harry

      lol

  • Pingback: Anonymity Unbound Cyber Babies vs. Cyber Bullies | Parcbench | Newborn Clothes

  • Pingback: Anonymity Unbound Cyber Babies vs. Cyber Bullies | Parcbench | Newborn

  • Alisha

    Hello,

    My names Alisha and I am a student at Holyhead School. I would appreciate the permission to use a picture for my coursework from your website please.

    can you please reply by e-mail with permission.

    Thank you for your help

    Regards.

  • Nathan

    Parcbench Team,

    I am a student at Our Lady & St.Bedes school and i am writing to request copyright for your Pictyre at the top. It will be used in my GCSE coursework entiled "Think Click" which is all about internet safety. This logo will not be used for commercial use just purely for my coursework.

    I am grateful for your time and look forward to hearing you in the future,
    Nathan Lee

  • diamond

    hi my name is diamond mcclendon and im 12 years old cyber bullying is a major problem and i can understand that!!!!!!!

  • tariya

    hi my name is tariya i used to be a cyber bully my self its hard to stop now a days theyhave these reporting a user boxes so you will missout on all the fun your friends are having if you dont stop its a major problem

  • Mathumitha

    Hi,

    As for my gcse ict project i want to know if i am allowed to use the picture which is used in this websites. this pictures is needed for my webpage which is about cyber bullying. which i would be happy if you reply me, saying if i am allowed or not. thank you

    – Mathumitha Mahendranathan
    villiers high school (yr 10 hf/ev)

  • ajal

    Hi,

    i am ajal. i am a year 10 student currentley doing a GCSE in ICT and i would like to use your image of the fist coming out of the computer screen and punching the boy in the face for my prodject. this will not enter the public domain and will only be used for internal use.
    please reply with permission if possible
    thank you
    Ajal Moktadir

  • Hannah Pither

    Hello,
    I am a year 10 pupil at The Marches school, i would like to you use you picture at the top for my Project called "think click" the project focuses on internet safety for primary children.
    This image will only been kept in the project and not publicized.
    I look forward to your reply for permission hopefully

    Thank you,
    Hannah Pither.