Quantcast

Avatar: A Bad Day for Conservatives? Think Again.

avatar1jpg-f70d0dd4a4f277bc_largeU.S. Marines blow up giant tree.  An ex-soldier discovers the wonders of mother-gaia and becomes defender of nature.

Sounds like “Fern Gulley 3” right?  No, it’s the most important film of the decade and it’s as liberal as hell.  The plot is about a group of corporate marines who attempt to infiltrate a village of 10-foot blue alien cat-people who worship a tree-goddess.

Jake Sully, a crippled soldier enlists in the ‘Avatar program’ which allows a human mind to control the body of a genetically grown alien.  But before your conservative blood starts boiling and refuse to take your kids to see a godless, new-age attack on America and all the traditional values you believe in, take a moment to consider what this film actually means for us.

Avatar is the most incredible movie I’ve ever seen.  It is, bottom line:  awesome.  The visual heft is more than enough to levitate a ‘been-there-done-that’ plot to wondrous heights.  That’s the main selling point.  It is an astoundingly beautiful and visceral film for being 95% artifice.  Each effects-laden sequence is filmed in eye-popping 3-D.

The main enhancement is the ability to channel facial emotion through motion capture.  It represents a new era in filmmaking, where even the most farfetched dreams can be made on-screen reality (provided you have half a billion dollars).  Choosing not to see this film would be an error akin to skipping out on the first Star Wars movie (and The Phantom Menace, this ain’t).  This not a movie that will be enhanced by repeated viewings, but you should at least see it once, if anything because it is a good diagnosis of the soul of the 21st Century American.

Avatar has interesting parallels to “The Matrix”, a film that also came out on the eve of a new decade (and a new millennium for that matter) and effectively set the stylistic tone for the following ten years of film.

The aesthetic of the Matrix turned superheroes and robots into well-dressed, culturally savvy, nihilistic ass-kickers that turned the ordinary world into a supernatural playground.  It was a critique, a comment, like Fight Club gone Anime and just about every action film since then has been realized under a thick layer of its influence.

Avatar represents a new paradigm that will likely have a similar cultural effect.  In The Matrix, robots make people think they’re living normal life when in fact they are just hooked into a computer program, an excellent comment on the pointlessness of modern consumerism.  But the problem with the Matrix was that even though it was a mental prison, it was still cooler than dirty derelict reality and you couldn’t wait for Keanu to jack back in and do flips and stuff.

Jake Sully is the anti-Neo who actually finds his true soul through the computer program.  He lives in a circuited society and finds escape from it through another reality and then gets lost in that reality.  This is simply a more accurate characterization of what it feels like to be a 21st Century American.

We lose ourselves in other realities all the time.  Sports, TV, golfing, World of Warcraft, alcohol, music, maybe even having an affair or changing one’s sexual identity.  However more or less socially acceptable your altered-reality of choice is, the reason remains constant:  we are tired of the reality we have built for ourselves and feel the need to ‘discover’ something else.

Wail on Obama haters but the truth is that, for good or ill, America is sick of anything status-quo no matter how solid the foundations may be.  There are no more illusions to be dispelled or barriers to be torn down, no square mile of land or sea left to discover.  Our great pioneer ancestors would be just as lost as we are today because they would have nothing to do.

There is simply nowhere else to go, no rock left unturned.  There’s just us earthlings bickering about whether to cap emissions or kill terrorists.  We are ready for another world.  Jake Sully is the new man of the age, one who is in touch with his own frailty and meaninglessness and hungers for something higher.  He will choose the ‘illusion’ that he is an alien over his human ‘reality’ because it is a better one.  Unlike Neo, he’s not coming ‘down to earth’ he’s rising up to heaven.  The story of Jake Sully is a religious one.  He wants to believe in something.  Avatar is the Matrix in reverse.

The truth is that Avatar is a historic movie no matter how you slice it.  Heavy-handed plot?  Sure.  Stereotypical characters?  Absolutely.  But those are minor details in the face of its visual grandeur, and rightfully so.  The film is a spectacular love letter to the supernatural wonders of the natural world and it would not have been possible but for highly advanced technology.

Hypocritical?  Maybe.  But we humans have always been a little backwards and Cameron knows it.  It’s built into the plot.  Jake uses hyper-technology to upload his mind into his alien body and only then dose he become one with nature and find purpose and meaning in life.  We use technology in order to escape it.

As for the bald-faced environmentalist message and the naïve ‘ham-handed’ anti-imperialist Dances With Wolves vibe:  maybe it is time to accept these themes as part of the national consciousness.  We are a part of a society that has done great good but also great evil.  We have stepped on and disrupted cultures.

Whatever you believe about climate change (and last I heard, the numbers were pretty clear), the truth is that we are a nation with a massive appetite for natural resources.  Are we to be a recalcitrant and gluttonous people?  A strong nation is one that knows how to atone for its sins.  How we respond to these issues is debatable but when you see Avatar, you’re going to find yourself wishing you were in Sully’s shoes.  My advice:  give in.  Set aside your political ho-humming and remember what it was like to be a kid again longing for adventure, romance and that ghostly feeling of purpose.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/perfidy2012 perfidy2012

    i'm sorry i didn't finish reading this. why is respecting mother earth a concept that opposes conservatism? i'm so pro marine that if i were infact a conservative i would most certainly identify with anything that didn't completely demonize them.

    • anon

      you should finish. It's my favorite review of this movie I read so far. :D

  • Adam D

    I am a conservative and I loved this movie! The corporation was willing to kill an entire race and ruin the ecosystem for access to a valuable mineral which was not theirs in the first place. Jake Sully and a handful of humans were willing to risk their lives to stop this. Since when do Conservatives support murder and stealing? I am not saying liberals do, but most conservatives can relate to Jake's character.

  • Wilgus

    Name me one robust initiative to address the enourmous environmental issues we face today put forth by the Republican party in the last ten years. One that doesn't involve hydrogen cell research.

    It's true Cameron hates Marines. Did you see The Abyss? Keep in mind these are corporate mercs, not government ones, but yeah they're still red-blooded Amer'cans. But Marine Corps as manifestation of societal will to power isn't too heinous an artistic leap to make. Soldiers are not a party unto themselves. The marines are a manifestation of evil goals, not the evil themselves (except maybe that guy w/ the scar on his face). You are right though, it does treat marines as if they just love nothing more than blowing stuff up.

  • http://www.facebook.com/alexwilgus Alex Wilgus

    Adam, my point is that the film isn't too kind to some of the things that conservatism holds dear, like a strong military, and the main Marine guy is totally a republican stereotype. The film also paints Western society as a rapacious juggernaut of callous expansion and tribal spiritualism as the better way to live. I'm not aware of too many conservatives who are into that. I'm trying to say that to really get at what the movie means for us you need to look past that surface stuff and into the character of Jake and his longing for higher things. Obviously, you did.

  • Robert Cotten

    What is it about this 'been there done that' plot and stereotypical characters that appeals to people so much. The absolutely stunning graphics do well enough to lift any plot to wondrous heights, but there is something to the character of Jake Sully. The thought that someone with whom many Americans can relate to (especially conservatives) has found an escape and purpose is exactly what many people of our generation need. Yeah, he becomes an alien, learns their ways and becomes a nature loving green to the core blue person, but he is a striking parallel to an 'upside down' Christ figure. Instead of descending, he transcends and for sure breaks the mold in plenty of other instances as well (not mentioning the love making he does in the process). Nevertheless, I was surprised to find a somewhat Christlike figure to be the centerpiece of a film that portrays tons of Hinduesque/spiritualistic tribalism beliefs. It is without doubt, a paramount film of epic proportion.

  • Weston

    Hey, and im a liberal. I just saw this movie a little while ago. 1)- Marines. These were private military men and women featured in the film (however i will agree the main military guy was a TOTAL stereotype)… and they liked to blow stuff up… now maybe James Cameron hates or likes the Marines, but seriously, does it matter?. 2)- Interesting quote from this article; "But before your conservative blood starts boiling and refuse to take your kids to see a godless, new-age attack on America and all the traditional values you believe in…" I mean come on! What kind of "values" are over consumption? What is wrong about holding the idea that maybe we should respect that which feeds our existence, instead of disregarding it? Call me a 'tree hugger' etc, but people need to get rid of this ignorant idea that everything is for us, and that we have a right to take all we desire. And in my view, this idea does not go by party lines… It is not a conservative issue as it is a liberal issue. Before people go and see this movie and treat it as political propaganda, they need to see it as a wake up call…

  • Ryan

    I'm a Canadian conservative, and since we support single payer health care, i doubt we'll have much in common hahaha. Some people have taken to bashing this movie, due to its obvious enviro-inded-messaging, but seriously, the reviewer has it right, I felt like I did when I was a little kid when everything was an adventure. We need to consume wisely, which i think is a goal conservatives can accept and one this movie really tries to emphasize. The visual effects…. well, just go see the movie. Its a glimpse of the future of filmmaking.

  • Pingback: Why Conservatives Should Love “Avatar” | NewsReal Blog

  • A. Guest

    I saw the movie (online) and regard it as unrecoverable time. The stereotypes were stereotypes; the "green" vision astoundingly simpleminded and glorified beyond sense. It's a children's horror story on film that lacks any form of balance but I didn't expect it to have any. As for film making wonders … who cares? Avatar is propaganda writ large and absurd. There are no lessons here and yes, it is a magnified version of Fern Gulley. The projection of the evil capitalist is boring, usual and less than one dimensional. I must say, I laughed out loud several times at not only the plot, but the dialogue and can only think that if I saw this crud in a theatre would've had upset the tender senses of too many Believers in "Mother" earth.

  • ward

    RE the numbers being clear on climate change (last paragraph). What planet have you been on. The fraud was exposed (again) weeks ago.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/RSassy RSassy

    Mr. Argus proclaims:
    "… maybe it is time to accept these themes as part of the national consciousness. We are a part of a society that has done great good but also great evil. We have stepped on and disrupted cultures.
    … the truth is that we are a nation with a massive appetite for natural resources. Are we to be a recalcitrant and gluttonous people? A strong nation is one that knows how to atone for its sins… My advice: give in. Set aside your political ho-humming and remember what it was like to be a kid again longing for adventure, romance and that ghostly feeling of purpose."

    It is this mentality, this condescending pseudo-spiritual tripe that makes my blood boil. You find your own sins to atone for Mr. Wilgus, and do not presume that you have the right to put the weight of your preposterous guilt on the rest of us. It always amazes me when self-righteous poseurs scoff at the West's purported gluttony while most obviously having partook at the trough themselves. More laughable is the apparent expectation that, should the West partake in your lugubrious acts of dismal contrition, that the rest of the world will assume the mantle of earth's guardians and forgo the earth's treasures or the accumulation of wealth and power. What a bloody idiotic world you have contrived.

    I'll end w/ a comment from someone to whom I skyped this bilge:
    "This A$$WIPE should look into some of the cultures the west has 'disrupted'…. He couldn't survive 10 seconds, the barbarisia."

    • Frank

      I find it sad that you view the West in such an immaculate light. Why do you consider it so shameful to consider or faintly acknowledge the fact that the Western way of doing things has carried (and will probably continue to do so) a burden of 'sins' or weight that brings a sort of distress to the world. To overlook this blatant fact is to remain blind or numb to reality. Self-righteousness more likely falls on those who consider themselves above the faults or guilt of a corporate nature rather than on those who bring it to light. Then again, judging from your tone, you probably hated the movie (or at least the "condescending pseudo-spiritual tripe" that it was clearly spouting) and found yourself waiting for somebody to write an article about it so you could waylay them.

  • Oleg Kostoglotov

    Perhaps the reviewer, Mr. Wilgus, should spend more time in the real world outside of the movie theater and Hollywood movie premiers. What is most disturbing is his incessant hand wring and guilt over the morality of the American economic system as a whole, something more consistent with a neo Marxist or "Liberal" then a conservative. The reality is that the most conspicuous consumption and decadent behavior in American society is exhibited by Hollywood liberal/socialists not Joe and Jane sixpack. What he views as bickering over cap and trade is a serious issue between liberty and tyranny or, to the man on the street, meaningful employment or Soviet style centrally planned economic stagnation and poverty based on what looks like a scientific fraud.
    Terrorism, on the other hand, is literally an issue of life and death and a struggle between barbarism and civilization as has just been illustrated by the near mass murder that occurred on Christmas day . The only reason the perp got as far as he did is because there is a reluctance in security circles to profile prospective terrorists thanks to political correctness and endless hand wringing about so called race issues.
    But like all Hollywood types James Cameron is so removed from reality that he, as a multi millionare, thinks that this drivel of a plot deserved a 1/2 billion dollar production budget. I don't care how remarkable the cinematography or special effects are it's the story that matters, I can think of a dozen or more science fiction and fantasy stories that would have been more deserving then a plot that would have been considered unworthy for a Saturday morning cartoon 20+ years ago. The original Matrix movie at least had an interesting premise for a story, not everything works but at least it makes one think, it wasn't cliche and it wasn't reliant on the special effects.

  • Joe

    You realize that by encouraging Conservatives to see this that you are only giving the Hollywood liberals more money to produce even more films that denigrate everything we believe in, right? No Conservative should spend their money to see this film or any other like it. Would a Conservative give money to Obama's re-election fund? Would they give money to gay marriage supporters or to ACORN? By seeing this film that is exactly what you are doing because those are the causes that the liberal filmmaker who you are enriching with your money supports.

    • Brehove

      wow you live in a small world

  • http://gamingaddict.today.com Samp

    You just killed a whole bunch of the plot for anybody that hasn't seen this by the way. Might want to think about warning someone next time…before you forever change how they'll view the movie because of your one-sided assessment.

  • beefyT

    This is the best review I have read of Avatar. It truly is an amazing movie, and this gives me an idea of why even Conservative middle-America enjoys it. To me the themes are universal and hopefully represent i change in mindset of the majority of 21st Century people. It obviously is very entertaining visually, and story-wise I think and the message this review takes from it is very interesting.

  • Pingback: April 23 2010 « Oh For Crying Out Loud…

  • Miss Australia

    IHi, Im a 27year old Australian, when I was a kid I loved Fern Gulley! Avatar is just like it!!!! How can they take all the credit when it is an updated copy of Fern Gulley???? With saying this is was a top movie:)